Reading the reviews in the NYT’s Books section, I noticed the many non-fiction histories of family members; that is, authors who choose to tell of their parents, grandparents or cousins’ life stories.
Granted, discovering your mother had a mortal secret she
carried unspoken all her life, or your father had a second family tucked in
plain sight you never knew about, or Cousin George turned out to have been an
enemy spy, all these are exciting and a gateway to a publishable book. After
all, you are a writer and have the justified appropriation via DNA.
But do you?
Both my parents lived rich and varied lives. I’ve been encouraged
by many to write about them. Especially about my father, who survived the Holocaust
to fight for the establishment of the state of Israel and was buried in
Jerusalem, where every religious Jew only dreams to end up. What a story.
And what about my mother, born to well-heeled parents in the
Golden country, the USA, only to abandon them and her comfortable life in order
to be part of building the new Jewish state, thus replacing a life of comfort
with hard physical work planting tomatoes in the scorching Israeli desert.
Life stories woven into the stories of a people. Isn’t that
a book?
But I will not write their stories. While my father lived,
he was urged by many to tell his own story and always refused. It seems an encroachment
on what was his story to tell and his alone, and something he would not have
wanted me to do. My father was a better writer than I ever could be and he
chose not to, and so it will have to be.
I have used many things from my own life in my fictional
stories, but writing a non-fiction biography of a family member has an almost pornographic
feel to it.
And if I had a Cousin George, I wouldn’t tell his story
either. The reason a publisher would pick it up is that I am distantly related,
which supposedly gives me some sort of bona fides, and the story is titillating.
You do you, but this doesn’t work for me. Telling on family,
whether scandalous or hagiographical, is something I would no more do than want
done to me. It’s the Golden rule.

































